atmosfair distributed efficient stoves in Nigeria since 2010. UN-accredited verifiers confirmed CO2 savings from operating stoves ex-post. Hamburg contract covered 75,000 tons using pre-existing stoves verified by 2020. New 15,000 stoves delayed until 2021 due to northern Nigeria terror attacks. Delays transparently communicated to Hamburg authority BUKEA. Welt article falsely claims stoves existed only on paper. UN reports for PoA 5067 prove stoves operated in 2018-2019. Hamburg Senate compensated with verified emissions reductions from real stoves. Rechnungshof cited wrong unrelated project CDM 2711. atmosfair corrected Rechnungshof in 2024 but ignored. Even cited UN report resolved the noted information gaps. CO2 savings accrue yearly from same ongoing stoves, no need for constant new ones. BUKEA confirmed to Rechnungshof that compensation met contract. atmosfair built own factory in Kano for new stoves post-delay.